Tuesday, December 23, 2008

A President runs a war.

Here are some comments on the book "Tried by war" about the way President Lincoln run the Civil War, mostly about the military side.
Let's start with Donald Rumsfeld's remark "You make war with the army you have" - yes - and with the President you have. Lincoln didn't have any military experience at all, neither did he have any army. The Federal Army counted just 16,000 troops, deployed on western forts. The General-in-Chief was Winfield Scott, famous hero of the Mexican war, but 75 years old, and frail of health, he didn't help much and retired soon.
An army of 637,000 volunteers was raised, equipped and trained by April 1862, one year after the start of the war. You need also Generals, 583 Generals were commissioned during the war, many by political patronage, a method as good as any. General Grant was sponsored by Elihu B. Washburne, chairman of the House Military Affairs Committee and General Sherman by his brother John, chairman of the Senate Finance Committee, without it they might have languished in obscurity.
For the post of commander of the Army of the Potomac (the biggest and most important army) Lincolm found the natural, proffesional, candidate 34 year old George B. McClellan, ranked second in his class at West Point, energetic, charismatic, adored by the soldiers, a good organizer, a good trainer of troops. Newspapers at the time called him "Young Napoleon". He was named to his command in July 1861, and soon after (November) General-in-Chief too. The only trouble with him is - he didn't like to fight. He was never ready, he always needed more troops, more horses or something. He never innitialized any battle, and never won one.
In July 1862 Lincoln named Henry W. Hallek General-in-Cheif (McClellan staying with the army of the Potomac). Hallek had written some books and was known as "Old Brains", he had a good administrative ability, but he was indecisive, and lacked the power to take control, impose his way and run things. Lincoln said he was a good clerck, and he needed him, so he kept him to the end of the war. In 1864, General Grant was named General-in-Chief, but Grant prefered to locate his headquartes in the field, near the army, so Hallek stayed on in Washington, as Chief-of-Staff.
It is remarkable how Lincoln couldn't find any military figure to run the war, and had to do it himself, single handed (at least until 1864, when he found Grant).
The problem wasn't solely the incompetece of the generals - there was plenty of that, but it also was much deeper - philisophical - about the aims of the war, the means to acheive them - derived from the aims. Lincoln believed you must seek out the enemy's army, engage it in battle and never let up until you destroy it. McClellan understood it would be an extreemly cruel, bloody enterprise. He had no stomach for such a total war of annihilation against fellow Americans. In the end, as presidential candidate in 1864, McCllelan embraced a settlement with the Confederacy. But Lincoln's aims were clear and firm, and undebatable: no independence to southern states and an end to slavery. He wouldn't settle on anything less, so no settlement was possible, and the bloodbath inevitable.
General Grant pursued the war as Lincoln wanted, not so much with brilliance, but with tenacity. He never rested, never let up, and the results followed - victory, but slowly - he suffered some bad settback at first - and at a terrible cost. Some called Grand a butcher. For example - in one two week period there were 30,000 casualties; in his first two months on the Potomac - some 90,000 (like McClellan suffered in 2 years). At first there weren't many gains to show for all these losses, and the impatient public seemed to sway toward the settlement.
Another interesting point is the question of strategy: the war's aims can, maybe, also be acheived by the indirect approach, by attacking not the enemy's main army, but his soft spots, untill you throw him off balance. This way you can acheive your aims with less losses. General McArthur employed this approach in WW2, he called it "hit them were they ain't". The approach wasn't known, or considered by Lincoln and his Generals, but was employed anyway, thanks to the brilliant initiative of General Sherman, who took an army of 60,000 veterans on a raid from Atalanta, Georgia, 287 miles, to the sea, at Savannah. Sherman raided the heart of the Confederacy hiterland, it's base of supply and economic and moral support. He renounced the securing of supply lines, lived off the country cut off from the Union, destroyed everything in his path. He outmaneuvered and outrun the enemy's army that was trying to stop him, he didn't seek battles, but rather succeded in avoiding them, acheiving his purpose without battles. He suffered almost no losses, but civilians in his path did suffer, mostly material losses. No wonder Sherman was the most intensly hated person in the South (maybe second only to Lincoln). Some say Sherman's raid was the decisive factor in ending the war.
The story of how Lincoln the inexperienced, unprepared politician run the whole war, including the military part, by himself, almost unaided, is fascinating.

What I missed in this book is a more objective approach to Lincoln, pointing out his mistakes, his missjudgements (if any). The Civil War was a very important, fundamental event, possitively: it abolished slavery, and maintained the Union. But it was also a terrible tragedy - more than 600,000 losses, and Lincoln presided over that too.
The book is an easy and absorbing read, it doesn't go into any details of military operations, but shows the events at the intersection between Lincoln and the military.


Anonymous said...


This is a inquiry for the webmaster/admin here at jacobress.blogspot.com.

May I use part of the information from this blog post above if I provide a link back to your website?


Anonymous said...

�?You just could not get this kind of benefit if you get into other stores around Working as a football coach[url=http://www.authenticnikeEaglesjersey.com]DeSean Jackson Jersey[/url]
you'll encounter a lot of exciting experiences[url=http://www.officialnikeBillsjerseys.com]Steve Johnson Jersey[/url]
and at the end of the day[url=http://www.jjwattjersey.com]JJ Watt Navy Jersey[/url]
you'll feel fulfilled when you win or even when you lose Well [url=http://www.brandonmarshalljersey.com]Brandon Marshall Women's Jersey[/url]
Wang ED[url=http://www.authenticnikeEaglesjersey.com]LeSean McCoy Jersey[/url]
his caree just began
These jerseys are available anywhere They love to collect various types of football collectibles like mugs[url=http://www.officialnikeBillsjerseys.com]C.J. Spiller Jersey[/url]
pens[url=http://www.andrewluckjerseys.net]Andrew Luck Authentic Jersey[/url]
photos[url=http://www.robertgriffiniiiJersey.net]Robert Griffin III Women's Jersey[/url]
posters[url=http://www.nikesteelersjerseyshop.com]Mike Wallace Jersey[/url]
jerseys and alike In any climate[url=http://www.authenticnikeLionsshop.com]Ndamukong Suh Jersey[/url]
moisture wicking[url=http://www.officialnflcoltssite.com]Pat Angerer Jersey[/url]
or sweat from the body transported to the outside air[url=http://www.nikecardinalsjerseyshop.com]Patrick Peterson Jersey[/url]
the cooling process is critical

Anonymous said...

1085 and are close to a fifty two week high and all time high of $112

You can watch all the 3000 channels streaming on the internet for free and right from your bedroom without ever going to the sitting room So they look around for ISK vendor[url=http://www.AndrewLuckJerseynike.com]Andrew Luck Authentic Jersey[/url]
and buying their high price ISK from those ISK sellers[url=http://www.elimanningjersey.net]eli manning jersey[/url]
which could get your account banned instantly In some variations[url=http://www.OwenDanielsJersey.com]www.OwenDanielsJersey.com[/url]
however[url=http://www.officialredskinsnflstore.com]Pierre Garcon Jersey[/url]
rosewood has been known to be June's wood
ï»?Bing says that these tags are not the best solution by using an example that says canonical source URLs only waste crawling bandwidth The portion of the cue where it is gripped with your swing hand will often have a wrap[url=http://www.PatrickWillisJersey.net]Patrick Willis Authentic Jersey[/url]
which is simply linen thread spooled to create a comfortable holdjpgarcticbeacon/cover_images/page6 He was also the 2000 Sprint Cup rookie of the year[url=http://www.victorcruzjerseys.net]www.victorcruzjerseys.net[/url]
after earning his chops at places like the Madison International Speedway[url=http://www.robertgriffiniiijersey.net]Robert Griffin III Womens Jersey[/url]
Slinger and WIRWeight Loss is Easy with Super Slim PomegranateMillions of people all around the world are looking for the right weight loss method[url=http://www.MattRyanJersey.net]www.MattRyanJersey.net[/url]
yet find that no diet programs fits their needs and lifestyle Liliane Bettencourt: $20 Insert the laminating pouch with the sealededge first into the paper carrier that is included with each carton of pouches

Anonymous said...

[url=http://longchampsacsa.blogcu.com/]sac longchamp[/url] I own both of these. I started with a PISA Top Fashion Mulberry Small Oliver Laptop Briefcase Brown for Men,Buy cheap Mulberry bags from Mulberry uk official factory shop. I bought a few days after the baby arrived. Pros: reliable pump, suction is good, easy to use (especially with a hands free bra). You can use reflective shoulder bags for practically nearly anything you want. These bags can be utilised as college bags, tote bags, or a bag that you carry close to each day. Most higher education pupils use a kind of shoulder bag to carry their books and provides to and from course.
[url=http://hujqingra.webgarden.com/]sac longchamp[/url] Scott Pilgrim thus manages to have its cake and eat it too, linking us to funny and beautiful emotions through the shared absurdity of our mutual cultural experiences. The manic fragmentation of Wright references ultimately leads us back to where we started: a need for connection, a way of laughing together, and a sense that we shared Scott triumphs and tragedies in our own New Fashion Mulberry Women's Mini Alexa Leather Satchel Light Coffee Bag, Mulberry Outlet online offer you high level quality Mulberry Bags at a low price. lives. That prevents us from detaching from the inspired silliness onscreen.
[url=http://maruta.be/longchampbagsd/]sac longchamp[/url] The answer then is pretty simple. During leading online retailers, including Replica Purses Seasoned pro, we good companies selling their particular Lv replacement products and services from cheap levels. They just don't skimp on concerning superior as well as help consumers have even the idea involving wearing jimmy choo shoes a duplicate, the cost is a great deal low. But if you know where to find the best deals and bargains, you will be able to shop for discounted designer handbags which come from the previous season. There are several brands of these handbags which are sold at cut-off prices. Examples of these are Fendi handbags, Prada handbags, Chloe handbags, D handbags, and Mulberry handbags.. We so lucky to live in the digital age where you Noble Fashion Mulberry Women's East West Bayswater Mixed Buckle shoulder Black Bag for sale at great price, fast delivery. can literally take 100 photos on your phone today and only keep your 3 favorites. I always think back to my high school self (who spent a lot of allowance money on packs of film) and imagine how blown away I would be if someone would have told me that in just 10 years time I have a phone that took better photos than my camera. The resources we have at our fingertips are truly incredible! Here are 5 tips for capturing your everyday life..

Anonymous said...

It not absolutely approaches me. Perhaps there are still variants?
I congratulate, it is simply magnificent idea
I congratulate, it seems brilliant idea to me is
Excellent idea
What excellent question

[url=http://mvpmichaelkors0.buzznet.com/user/journal/17307946/history-handbags/][b]michael kors outlet online[/b][/url]
[url=http://shenenmaoyif.blog.hr/][b]michael kors outlet online[/b][/url]
[url=http://shenenmaoyitt.exteen.com/20130118/chanel-bags-authentic-and-genuine][b]michael kors outlet online[/b][/url]
[url=http://shenenmaoyipp.sosblogs.com/The-first-blog-b1/Eye-Catching-Luggage-Tags-Make-Finding-Bags-Simpler-b1-p1.htm][b]michael kors outlet online[/b][/url]
[url=http://cheapmichaelkors1.manifo.com/][b]michael kors outlet online[/b][/url]